The therapeutic landscape for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) has been characterized by decades of clinical trial failures, often attributed to biological heterogeneity, end-point insensitivity, and a profound evidence gap regarding target engagement. With TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) aggregation emerging as a hallmark feature in the vast majority of ALS cases, new precision-medicine modalities – most notably the proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) CTx1000 – aim to address the underlying causal pathology through selective degradation of mislocalized TDP-43. This review critically evaluates the regulatory hurdles and trial design deficiencies that have historically undermined ALS clinical development, and incorporates the dual sequestration hypothesis as a framework to interpret the convergence of TDP-43 pathology across neurodegenerative diseases. It concludes that it is imperative that the field adopts more rigorous biomarker-led methodologies, and that although target-specific degraders offer a sophisticated technological leap, their success depends on addressing fundamental knowledge gaps in target engagement, age-dependent vector tropism, and trial design architecture.