Progressive Catholic, Liberal Catholic


Discussion Board



A discussion forum on theology, faith, doubt, prayer,

the afterlife, and other religious topics.



Ascension of Jesus ChristThe Transfiguration of Jesus Christ Beatitudes Sermon on the Mount of Jesus Christ Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of God
I have been thinking about your message below all day long since you posted it yesterday. In fact, I plan to save it on c: drive for future reflection.

The story about the man in the desert who is shown the way by an explorer "before God had time to answer," is both funny and precious.

But I was hoping to explore with you the last two paragraphs of your message. What is the point of listening through contemplative prayer to God who does not speak but is listening as well? The person is making time available for God to speak to him or her through his or her mind. But suppose a person sits for 30 minutes with nothing in mind, just sits, empty mind, meditating, maybe gazing at a religious picture, but nothing going on in his mind. Is that religion? Does that give glory to God?

For that matter, you could do this type of contemplation sitting in a car in a parking lot. Is that less aesthetically pleasing than contemplating by a brook and listening to the calming effect of the water passing in the brook?

If I sit in my bedroom and just listen -- there is silence. Should I do that 3 hours per day? If it is pleasing to God, then presumably, the more time I make for God and this type of cleared-mind, untroubled contemplation, the better.

Mike

P.S. Does it seem ironic that everyone would say it is bad to sit in the kitchen staring at the phone, waiting for it to ring --- but essentially, we are doing that same thing sitting in contemplation perhaps with no expectation of receiving any message, or waiting in case some message does arrive in our minds.
THIS SITE:
(1) DISCUSSION BOARD HOME
(2) HENRI NOUWEN SOCIETY MEDITATIONS
(3) POST A COMMENT by e-mail

Saint Anthony St. Anthony of Padua


Michelangelo The Pieta


Resurrection of Jesus Christ



St. Thomas Merton Trappist Monk and Theologian, Saint Thomas Merton

St. Theresa of Lisieux, The Little Flower, Saint Theresa Martin

St. Teresa of Avila, Saint Teresa of Avila



Click here. Post a comment.

We want to hear from you.